ADR3-N's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[firework love]

Overall, I love the vocal lines and overall theme. Actually, I think you could roll off the high end of the vocal a bit, and experiment with both low and hi pass on it.

The mix in general is quite sibilant. I find myself wanting your kick fuller, more snare volume, and less sibilants all around, including on your synths. The mix is lacking low mid, and could use a heavier bass, perhaps down an octave.

Otherwise, great ideas. Love it! I honestly would ask for an acapella. I think you have a beautiful voice, and that chorus is infectious!

Kiiri responds:

if you really do want the thing I can provide it

do be aware I sound much worse without every instrument ever drowning me out

[3Dodge]

In terms of composition, great!

Mix and instrumentation wise, there are some things I would change. For one, the mix is pretty quiet and it sounds to be unmastered. Some compression would do you lots of favors applied to the master channel -- careful to do this once you are satisfied with how you want your song to be, and not during the entire process. Even an internet mastering service would help.

In terms of individual instruments, your lead guitar is a little dry sounding. It could use a chorus, delay, or reverb to give it some space. The same is occurring with most other leads, so they sound flat.

Your rhythm guitars could be double tracked

Your kick and snare should be the loudest parts of your mix. hi-hats are a bit too loud. They should be audible but not overly obvious.

Brass could also be panned wider for effect and other instruments used to double this part for extra texture

The breathing SFX through 1:26 could be panned left or right for effect

Otherwise, hold onto this idea. It's a fantastically written piece that just needs some polish!

Jotrocken responds:

Unfortunately i can't use my project file anymore. Due to some problems with Komplete Kontrol/ NI VST (Support could help either).
But I keep that in mind for future mixes and mastering or if i someday make a new mix.

Really appreciate your feedback.

[In My Dreams (ft. Katty Heath)]

Some pretty banging trance! I wish there were a bit less reverb on portions, to make that sidechain a bit more effective. At points the pianos sound like they are overdriving, especially on the sides and in the right channel around 2 min.

The vocals also could be mixed a bit louder overtop the instrumental. Less reverb on the pads or a sidechain on it when the vocals come in would help

Otherwise, great!

Olindel responds:

Thank you very much! I'll apply these improvements for my next track!

[Burrito Monkey]

I think this is a very interesting idea, but it's pretty short, and the loudest instrument is your.. bell lead? I hear some guitar samples out of key with that, but they're quiet enough to be noise.

What I would like is to hear more of your kick and snare, so that they cut through the beat and give it some more oomph

That bass line is not a bad idea at all. It's pretty interesting, but it shouldn't be all that I can hear clearly. Other than that, not bad, just wish it were longer!

JAM-POWER responds:

Thanks for the feedback! (Sorry it took me a while to respond)

[Chocnoon - Nadir (CCCXXVI)]

This piece is pretty muddy -- lots of reverb, lots of choruses or delays that are bleeding together and impeding the clarity of mix. Snare is not audible over them. I advise turning down instruments until the kick and snare are the loudest in the mix, and turning down hihats until they are not prominent.

I don't really like the high kick. It sounds like it is not in the same key.

Your writing is not bad but looking at the track, you see that virtually every section is the same volume, and there are not a lot of transitions or identifiable sections except key changes.

In short I like your melodies a lot but there is a lot covering them up, and they could use to be developed more. No matter what though, don't stop producing what makes you happy. The only person you should really compete with is yourself as you were yesterday. Don't stop until you make the kind of music that makes you rave <3 The problems I'm telling you about, I have experienced for years, and I still do sometimes. Keep it up. I believe in you!

name responds:

Thanks!

[e v e n w h e n t h i n g s g o w r o n g]

I think the intro vinyl is a bit too loud relative to the chords coming in, as is the sweep! However, olskool feel is a vibe

The low mids on the piano at 1:04 could be tamed, and a bit more high end until 1:21 allowed for.

1:28 that transition noise is a bit sibilant and loud! Thoughout it is quite evident. I would advise to pick either one or the other -- loud and not sibilant, or quieter and still sibilant

I love your melodic lines.

Beyond those minor gripes, I don't have much for you. Great work!

icantpronouncethis responds:

Thank you for taking your time and listening and leaving suggestions.
Definitely gonna work on my mixing games.

[Aqua[cult]ure (Kallamar’s Theme)]

Going to leave a 5 here because I hate zero bombers. My NGUAC score will differ. Much love to you and sorry you're dealing with dumb GD players not knowing how this site works, not to mention that they do not have rights to use any song they want in GD. I say that as someone who enables all my songs for use. Not everyone wants that, and that's okay.

As a composition this flows flawlessly, no complaints there.

Mix wise I have some gripes, few
mix is sub heavy at sections such as 3:18, and snare is hiding in the mix. I want to hear more of the high mids on your basses

It actually sounds like the song was mixed loud and compressed down, as the issues of clarity improve drastically on thinner sections which do not have your sub bass throbbing.

at 1:14, clarity is an issue -- the reverb of the pads and sub is washing out your build under that tight compression.

Hiccup at 1:33. I think your synth had a minor midi stroke

In general I would prefer less reverb, less volume before hitting the compressor, heavier use of sidechain

2:15 you have toms that I can't hear over the reverb, which I would love pushed to the front! Occasional fills of those would be nice, with some sidechain or some such to help them cut.

Hihats and cymbals sound like they are pushed high to compensate for lack of clarity. I think pushing them down and snare up would help.

Otherwise, really enjoyed it. Great composition and smooth writing all the way through!

GlowBoyMusic responds:

Wow! This is such a wonderful and comprehensive review! Thank you so much for this!

I currently have a limited amount of music tech due to practically living off of commissions, so soon things might sound better just by that alone, but overall, I value this highly!

Thank you ever so much for this review, and have a great day!

-- Glow

[Stasis]

Ahahaha this description is story of my life xD I had to change my buffer rate for mine

Appreciating the sort of ambient foray we're going into here. Like ambient lofi hiphop.

Those sweeping pads could actually use a bit less air/volume relative to your 808. 808 needs to come up by quite a bit. Lead could also use a bit more width, chorus, and perhaps delay to fit into the wide sonic space of those pads and pull the track together.

Overall the melodic element to the piece is quite short relative to the ambient. I think I would have liked a longer piece with more developed phrases. HOWEVER I will say as I haven't heard anything like this from you before I really enjoy the experimental journey you're going on and aside from mix aspects this would have been a solid 8.5/10 for me!

GlaceonDash responds:

Thank you! It's apart of just trying to find my musical identity.

[Timeless Ibis]

Could benefit from a master -- the mix is quiet!
But writing is fantastic. There are a few bones I have to pick with mix, such as kick and snare not always being upfront and clear, but overall is clean and easy to hear all important elements

Great work!

death2go responds:

Thanks! I definitely can understand needing to try to make the mix louder and polish up on a mastering, though, Though, it feels odd that it renders out quieter than what the DAW is that, i found out recently that my Master mixer Volume Exceeds what a lot of people would consider normal mixing volume, so I've been adjusting that and trying to experiment on trying to increase the volume so it matches closer to other songs. I don't like the idea of someone having to turn their volume up to listen to this, then going to another song and getting blasted because they forgot to adjust their volume. maybe whenever I understand it a bit more later down the line, I'll go through the songs that have this issue and update them! Thanks for the review! It means alot!!

[Evidence Of A Creator]

Could benefit from mastering for volume level (the mix is FANTASTIC), but otherwise, this is a stellar piece, with great modulations and lead writing. Sounds like something straight out of Final Fantasy 13-2. Like discovering time travel. Nice!

DarkGod666 responds:

Appreciate the comparison! I love the more experimental vibe of that ost. I suppose I could have clipped the transients more and pushed up the volume a bit, yeah.